Health Insurance
The 2010 political cartoon by A.F.
Branco titled “New Crimes” address the health insurance policy in America. Health
Insurance is insurance that covers your health care expenses. It is something
that all people should have in case of an accident. It is very expensive though
and some people can’t afford it. The political cartoon I chose was of two guys
in a jail cell talking. The guy on the left is a murderer and the guy on the
right is a person who didn’t buy health insurance. To me this cartoon is
talking about Obama Care. I also think it is showing that people who don’t want
Obama Care and trying to tell other Americans not to vote for it because if you
don’t buy it you will end up in jail.
This cartoon shows exaggeration
because the guy who didn’t buy health insurance would never be in the same cell
as the guy who murdered twelve people. The murderer also has a knife or sharp
object and in jail they make sure nobody has objects people could use for
killing. There is also writing on the back wall that reads “Manson was here.”
Charles Manson was a murderer in the 1960’s. The odds of that jail cell being
Charles Manson’s is pretty low. This cartoon doesn’t have many symbols but it has
some that do a good job representing what they are. The guy on the left is a
big, tough looking guy with a knife and tattoos. Anyone can see that he
represents a criminal or bad guy. The guy on the left is a skinny guy with a
suit on. This just represents a normal working man.
The “New Crimes” caption is in big
letters and is one of the first things you see. It is saying that not buying
health insurance is the new way to get in trouble with the government. Below
the caption there are two words that read “Freedoms Battle.” This helps readers
see that America is trying to fight for their freedom. If they don’t want to
buy health insurance then why should they be made to do so? Getting in trouble
for not buying health insurance is just another way that is standing in the way
of people that believe in freedom. I wasn’t sure if it had visual irony but I
thought it was pretty ironic that the guy that didn’t buy health insurance is
in the same cell as the guy who murdered twelve people.
This
cartoon lacks caricature and iconography but it shows the struggle of fighting
for freedom and what government is doing to try and make you buy health
insurance. A.F. Blanco is saying what he believes is unfair and people have the
right to do what they want. I didn’t know much about this cartoon at first but
after I read what other people thought I started to understand. Health care is
something someone should have but shouldn’t be forced to have it.

I agree with your claim about health care being a good idea but it shouldn't be a requirement. Just because you didn't buy health care doesn't mean you should get the same punishments as a person who murdered someone.
ReplyDeleteI really like how you break down the elements in the cartoon in the first two paragraphs. Your explanation of how exaggeration is used is clear and I agree with your reasoning. You mention that the cartoon lacks caricature, but I think you actually describe the caricature of a criminal when you explain how "The guy on the left is a big, tough looking guy with a knife and tattoos. Anyone can see that he represents a criminal or bad guy."
ReplyDelete